Divorce and custody cases involving domestic violence allegations are some of the most emotionally charged, difficult, and complex cases. If you or the other party has claimed that there was abuse in your relationship it can affect everything from the proofs to how negotiations and settlement are handled. Here's what you need to know about domestic violence and mediation, so you can decide if alternative dispute resolution is right for you.
Will Your Michigan Divorce or Custody Case Be Sent to Mediation?
The Michigan Family Courts rely on mediation to resolve most of the cases that come before them. That is because, in most cases, settlement is the better option for everyone involved in a divorce or custody case. Most Michigan divorce and custody actions will be automatically referred to mediation before they are set for trial. This doesn't mean you have to come to an agreement on important issues like custody, parenting time, spousal support or property divisions. But it does mean the Court will expect you to sit down at the (often virtual) negotiating table before proving your case in court.
If your case is referred to mediation, either the Court or the attorneys in the case will select a domestic relations mediator from an approved list. The mediator doesn't have to be a lawyer, but they do have to have relevant education and professional history (including as a therapist, counselor, or social worker) and have completed domestic relations mediation training.
Domestic Violence Exception to Mediation Requirements
However, the general rule favoring settlement and mediation breaks down in cases of actual or alleged domestic violence or abuse. Because of this, the Michigan Court Rules allow either party to file a motion to remove the case from mediation and set the matter for a hearing before the judge (or a Friend of the Court Referee) instead. Cases that can be excluded from mandatory mediation include any case with allegations involving:
- Child abuse or neglect
- Domestic violence toward a spouse or intimate partner
- Either party's inability to negotiate for him or herself (including cases where one party is not legally competent)
- One or both parties' health or safety would be endangered by mediation
- Other good cause
All Michigan mediators are also trained to screen their cases for concerns about domestic violence and coercive control. If they believe that mediation would be unsafe for either party, or that the parties' history would prevent them from reaching a voluntary and safe resolution to the issues, the mediator may ask the Court to remove the case from mediation.
Why Mediation Often Isn't Appropriate in Domestic Violence Cases
For mediation to be successful, the parties need to be able to cooperate, speak freely, and negotiate for their own interests. But in cases of domestic violence or coercive control, there is often a power imbalance. The abusive partner often has more resources, information, understanding, and support, in addition to an emotional advantage over the survivor based on the parties' history of fear, violence, and intimidation.
When couples with this kind of unequal bargaining power sit down at the mediation table, the abusive partner can put that power dynamic to work pressuring the surviving partner into a decision that is not in his or her best interest. As a result, when there are allegations of domestic violence, the parties' ability to voluntarily agree to any settlement proposal is in question. Survivors often end up agreeing to unfavorable terms just to get out of the uncomfortable situation of having to face their abusers.
Things to Consider if You Decide to Mediate in a Domestic Violence Case
Even though domestic violence and mediation don't always go together, working with an attorney who has experience with the effect of abuse and domestic violence on survivors can reduce the risk of an unfair outcome. The court rules allow mediation to continue in domestic violence actions as long as both parties' lawyers are present. If you and your attorney do decide mediation is the right choice consider:
Asking the Mediator to Use Electronic Shuttle-Style Mediation
If the survivor spouse or partner says he or she is intimidated to be around the alleged abuser, you may still be able to mediate if your mediator will agree to a limited or no-contact formal. Many modern mediators prefer to hold virtual mediations, where each party attends a video conference from his or her attorney's office. This puts physical distance between the parties and reduces the risk of safety concerns. If just seeing the alleged abuser is a problem, the mediator can also “shuttle” between the two parties, so that they never have to discuss settlement issues face-to-face.
Having a Plan for Dealing with Emotional Strain and Traumatic Triggers
Mediation can take a long time, especially in a complicated divorce action. You need to be prepared for the strain of going through the process. If you experience anxiety or other mental health issues related to your history of domestic violence, talk to your therapist to develop a plan for dealing with those emotions in the high-stress environment of the mediation. This could include bringing snacks, asking for breaks, or even having a support person waiting outside to help you through the process.
Being Ready to Walk Away if Negotiations Fail
Survivors often struggle with saying no to their abusers out of fear that they will experience verbal, emotional, or even physical abuse in retaliation. For mediation to work in a domestic violence setting, you need to know in advance what your hard lines are and what you cannot give up. While mediation requires compromise, it does not mean that you need to give up on something that is important to you just to please your former partner. If a boundary gets crossed, you will simply need to walk away and take the case to trial.
Staggering Exits from In-Person Mediation Sessions
Often, no one is entirely happy at the end of mediation. Sacrifices and compromises will be made if things go well, and parties will be angry or disappointed if no resolution can be reached. If you are meeting in person, ask your mediator to stagger the parties' exits. Ideally, the party alleging abuse should be allowed to leave first, and then the alleged abuser. This prevents the alleged abuser from following the survivor, potentially harassing or even assaulting him or her after the mediation is over.
Having a Support Plan for After Mediation
For this same reason, it is a good idea for both parties to have a plan in place for how they will receive support after mediation is over. This could be as simple as getting dinner or drinks with some friends. You might schedule an extra session with your therapist. However, in the most severe cases, survivors should also create a safety plan where they do not stay in their own home the night of the mediation, so that their abuser will not know where to find them if things go poorly.
Get Help Navigating Your Domestic Violence Action
At Bebout, Potere, Cox & Bennion, P.C., we care about you and your family. We help individuals and families in Rochester Hills, Rochester, Troy, Lake Orion, Oxford, Oakland County, Macomb County and throughout Southeast Michigan. We can help you navigate the interplay of domestic violence and mediation in your divorce or custody case. Call us at 248-651-4114 or contact us here to speak to an attorney.
